Assertion (A): Diamond, a non-metal, has a very high melting point, so a high melting point cannot be used on its own to decide that an element is a metal.
Reason (R): Diamond is an allotrope of carbon.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 62 of 80
Assertion (A): Diamond, a non-metal, has a very high melting point, so a high melting point cannot be used on its own to decide that an element is a metal.
Reason (R): Diamond is an allotrope of carbon.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true, but R is false.
(D) A is false, but R is true.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The Assertion is true, and it needs two steps. First, diamond is the hardest natural substance known and has a very high melting and boiling point, although it is a non-metal. Second, high melting point is one of the properties used to recognise metals; since a non-metal can have it too, the property is not decisive on its own. (The same is true from the other side: gallium and caesium are metals with very low melting points.)
The Reason is true. Carbon can exist in different forms, and each form is called an allotrope. Diamond and graphite are both allotropes of carbon.
But R does not explain A. Being an allotrope of carbon only says that diamond is one of the forms in which carbon exists. Graphite is also an allotrope of carbon, yet its properties are very different: it conducts electricity, which diamond does not. So being an allotrope of carbon does not, by itself, tell us anything about melting point, and it says nothing about why melting point is an unreliable test. A is explained by diamond being an exception among non-metals, not by its being an allotrope.
Option (A) is wrong: it treats R as the explanation, but being an allotrope of carbon does not by itself give an element a very high melting point.
Option (C) is wrong: R is true; diamond is an allotrope of carbon.
Option (D) is wrong: A is true; diamond is a non-metal with a very high melting point, so melting point alone cannot identify a metal.
