Read the following and answer all the sub-questions.
Metals and non-metals are usually told apart by a short list of physical properties. Almost every item on that list, however, has an exception.

| Element | Observation |
|---|---|
| Mercury | a metal, yet a liquid at room temperature |
| Bromine | a non-metal, yet a liquid at room temperature |
| Graphite (carbon) | a non-metal, yet it conducts electricity well |
| Iodine | a non-metal, yet shiny and lustrous |
| Sodium | a metal, yet soft enough to cut with a knife, melting at 98 °C |
(a) Which two observations break the same general rule from opposite sides? State the rule. [1]
(b) Iodine is lustrous, yet it is a non-metal. In potassium iodide (one of the salts used in Activity 3.13), iodine is present as the ion. Explain how this shows that iodine is a non-metal. [1]
(c) A student concludes: "Since there are so many exceptions, dividing the elements into metals and non-metals is useless." Give a reasoned response. [1]
(d) Which one property would you trust to classify an unknown element as a metal or a non-metal, and why? Use sodium and iodine as your examples. [1]
