Assertion (A): A crystal of sodium chloride shatters when it is struck with a hammer, whereas a piece of copper flattens.
Reason (R): The forces of attraction between the ions in sodium chloride are strong.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 52 of 80
Assertion (A): A crystal of sodium chloride shatters when it is struck with a hammer, whereas a piece of copper flattens.
Reason (R): The forces of attraction between the ions in sodium chloride are strong.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true, but R is false.
(D) A is false, but R is true.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The Assertion is true. Ionic compounds such as sodium chloride are generally brittle: they break into pieces when pressure is applied. Metals such as copper are malleable: they can be beaten into thin sheets, so a hammer blow flattens them instead of breaking them.
The Reason is true. The ions in sodium chloride are held together by strong forces of attraction between the oppositely charged ions. This is why ionic compounds are hard solids and have high melting and boiling points (sodium chloride melts at 1074 K): a considerable amount of energy is needed to overcome these forces.
But R does not explain A. Strong attraction between the ions explains why sodium chloride is hard and difficult to melt, not why it shatters instead of flattening. A strong force on its own would, if anything, suggest the crystal should hold together. The shattering is simply the brittleness of ionic compounds, a separate property, and it is set against the malleability of a metal.
Option (A) is wrong: R is true, but it accounts for the hardness and high melting point of sodium chloride, not for its shattering.
Option (C) is wrong: R is true; the attraction between the ions in sodium chloride is strong.
Option (D) is wrong: A is true; sodium chloride is brittle and copper is malleable.

How the ions in an ionic compound are formed and held together.