Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Metals in their pure state have a shining surface; this property is called metallic lustre. Most metals, however, slowly react with the oxygen, moisture and other gases of the air, and the products form a thin, dull layer on the surface (for example a layer of oxide). This layer hides the lustre. Sandpaper scrapes the layer away and exposes fresh, pure metal, so the rubbed part shines. Left in air for a long time, the fresh surface would slowly dull again.
Option (B) is wrong: rubbing a non-metal such as sulphur or a piece of coal with sandpaper does not make it shine, because most non-metals are not lustrous at all (iodine is an exception). The shine appears because these samples are metals.
Option (C) is wrong: rubbing cannot change one element into another. All four samples are metals all along; only their surface layer was dull.
Option (D) is wrong: the heat produced by rubbing with sandpaper is far too small to melt metals such as iron or copper, which have high melting points; the shine comes from removing the surface layer, not from melting it.

Five elements that break the usual metal / non-metal rule; iodine is the lustrous non-metal.