A student mixes 20 mL of a dilute acid of pH 1 with 20 mL of a dilute base of pH 12 in a beaker. She then drops a marble chip into the mixture, and it fizzes.
Which conclusion is correct?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 4 of 80
A student mixes 20 mL of a dilute acid of pH 1 with 20 mL of a dilute base of pH 12 in a beaker. She then drops a marble chip into the mixture, and it fizzes.
Which conclusion is correct?
(A) No reaction took place between the acid and the base, because the mixture is still acidic.
(B) The acid and the base reacted to form a salt and water, but there was more acid than the base could neutralise, so some acid is left.
(C) The mixture is neutral, because equal volumes of an acid and a base always neutralise each other exactly.
(D) The base was left over after the reaction, and the base is what reacts with the marble chip.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Two facts have to be put together.
So acid is still present after the reaction. The base was used up before all the acid had been neutralised: the mixture contains the salt, water and some leftover acid. Equal volumes do not mean equal amounts of acid and base: here the acid (pH 1) is far more acidic than the base (pH 12) is basic.
Option (A) is wrong: an acid and a base always neutralise each other when they are mixed; a mixture can stay acidic simply because the acid was in excess.
Option (C) is wrong: a neutral mixture would not make marble fizz; equal volumes neutralise exactly only if they contain matching amounts of acid and base.
Option (D) is wrong: a base does not give carbon dioxide with a carbonate; the fizzing shows that acid, not base, is left over.
