Solid sodium hydrogencarbonate is the better choice.
2NaHCO3(s)+H2SO4(aq)→Na2SO4(aq)+2H2O(l)+2CO2(g)
Reasons (any two):
- An excess does no harm. Sodium hydrogencarbonate is a mild, non-corrosive basic salt, so if more is added than the acid needs, what is left is a harmless powder. Sodium hydroxide is a strong, corrosive alkali: any excess would itself be a dangerous spill, swapping an acid spill for an alkali one.
- It is a solid. It stays where it is sprinkled. Pouring a solution on the bench spreads the liquid and the acid over a larger area.
- Less heat in one place. A strong alkali poured onto the acid reacts with it all at once and releases a lot of heat in one spot; a sprinkled solid reacts more gently.
Knowing when to stop: the reaction gives off carbon dioxide, so the powder fizzes while acid is still present. When a fresh sprinkle of powder no longer fizzes, all the acid has been neutralised. Sodium hydroxide gives no such visible signal, so the student could not tell when to stop without an indicator.
