Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Write both reactions:
Na2CO3+2HCl→2NaCl+H2O+CO2
NaHCO3+HCl→NaCl+H2O+CO2
R is true: the equations show 2 HCl for each Na2CO3 and 1 HCl for each NaHCO3.
A is true. Both equations give one CO2 for each formula unit of the solid, so the solid that contains more formula units in 1 g gives more gas. That is the lighter formula unit:
- Na2CO3: 2(23)+12+3(16)=106 u
- NaHCO3: 23+1+12+3(16)=84 u
Since 84 u is smaller than 106 u, 1 g of sodium hydrogencarbonate contains more formula units than 1 g of sodium carbonate, and so gives more carbon dioxide (about 8444=0.52 g against 10644=0.42 g).
But R does not explain A. R is about how much acid each solid uses up. The acid is in excess here, so the amount of acid used does not limit anything, and both solids give one CO2 per formula unit regardless. The difference in gas comes entirely from the difference in formula mass, which R does not mention.
Option (A) is wrong: R is true, but it accounts for the acid used, not for the extra carbon dioxide.
Option (C) is wrong: R correctly states the ratios in the two balanced equations.
Option (D) is wrong: A is true, as the formula masses show.
