The atmosphere of the planet Venus is made up of thick clouds of sulphuric acid. A student argues: "Life like ours could survive there. Our stomach already contains hydrochloric acid, and we are fine."
Which is the best reply to the student?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 20 of 80
The atmosphere of the planet Venus is made up of thick clouds of sulphuric acid. A student argues: "Life like ours could survive there. Our stomach already contains hydrochloric acid, and we are fine."
Which is the best reply to the student?
(A) Sulphuric acid is a weak acid, so it would do no harm to living things.
(B) Living organisms can survive only within a narrow range of pH (our body works at pH 7.0 to 7.8), and sulphuric acid would push the pH of their body fluids far outside this range.
(C) The stomach acid would neutralise the sulphuric acid, so living things would be protected.
(D) Life is impossible there only because sulphuric acid conducts electricity.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Our body works within a pH range of 7.0 to 7.8, and living organisms can survive only within a narrow range of pH change. That is why acid rain, with a pH below 5.6, makes it difficult for aquatic life to survive in rivers. Clouds of sulphuric acid, a strong acid, would expose living things to a pH far lower still.
The stomach is a special case: it produces hydrochloric acid on purpose to help digest food, and too much of it causes pain. That does not mean the body as a whole can live in acid.
Option (A) is wrong: sulphuric acid is a strong acid, not a weak one.
Option (C) is wrong: stomach acid is itself an acid, so it cannot neutralise another acid; only a base can do that.
Option (D) is wrong: conducting electricity is not what makes an acid harmful; the problem is how acidic it is, that is, its very low pH.
