(a) Carbon dioxide first reacts with the calcium hydroxide in lime water to form insoluble calcium carbonate, which makes the liquid milky. Student A stopped at this stage:
Ca(OH)2(aq)+CO2(g)→CaCO3(s)+H2O(l)
Student B kept bubbling. Once all the calcium hydroxide had been used up, the excess carbon dioxide reacted with the suspended calcium carbonate and water to form calcium hydrogencarbonate, which is soluble:
CaCO3(s)+H2O(l)+CO2(g)→Ca(HCO3)2(aq)
The white solid dissolved, so the liquid went clear again. His lime water almost certainly went milky in the first few seconds while he was not watching.
His conclusion is wrong because a clear liquid at the end does not mean that nothing happened. The carbon dioxide was not rejected; it was absorbed twice over and is now held in solution as hydrogencarbonate. The milky stage is the test, and it has to be watched for at the start.
(b) He should add dilute hydrochloric acid to the clear solution, and bubble any gas given off through a fresh tube of lime water.
He would see effervescence, and the gas would turn the fresh lime water milky. Calcium hydrogencarbonate is a metal hydrogencarbonate, and every metal hydrogencarbonate reacts with an acid to give a salt, water and carbon dioxide:
Ca(HCO3)2(aq)+2HCl(aq)→CaCl2(aq)+2H2O(l)+2CO2(g)
If no carbon dioxide had been absorbed, his tube would still hold only lime water, a base, which the acid would simply neutralise without giving any gas. So getting carbon dioxide back out of his solution proves that the carbon dioxide had been absorbed into it, which is exactly what his conclusion denied.
