(a) The ion is H+ (present in water as H3O+).
The table works as a set of controlled comparisons:
- Cl− is ruled out: sodium chloride contains Cl− but does not change blue litmus.
- NO3− is ruled out: potassium nitrate contains NO3− but has no effect.
- SO42− is ruled out: sodium sulphate contains SO42− but has no effect.
- Na+ and K+ are ruled out: they are not present in any of the solutions that turn litmus red.
Each acid shares its negative ion with one of the salts, and that salt does nothing, so the negative ion cannot be responsible. The only ion that every solution turning litmus red contains, and that none of the others contains, is H+.
(b) Ammonium chloride is the salt of hydrochloric acid, a strong acid, and ammonium hydroxide, a weak base. A salt of a strong acid and a weak base gives an acidic solution, with a pH below 7. So its solution contains more H+ ions than pure water does, and these turn blue litmus red, even though the solid itself is a salt and not an acid. This fits the conclusion in (a): litmus responds to H+ ions, whatever substance put them there.
(c) These reactions are also reactions of H+ ions. With zinc, the H+ ions of hydrochloric and sulphuric acid are turned into hydrogen gas; with marble (calcium carbonate), they react with the carbonate to release carbon dioxide and water. The negative ions, Cl−, NO3− and SO42−, take no part and end up in the salt. Since the acids supply the same H+ ions in water, they show the same reactions. (Nitric acid is left out of the zinc test because it is a strong oxidising agent: it oxidises the hydrogen to water, so it does not normally give hydrogen gas with metals.) H+ ions are what all acids have in common.