(a) She should add zinc, as a fine powder, in excess. Zinc is more reactive than copper, so it displaces copper from copper sulphate. The product is zinc sulphate, the very substance the bottle is meant to contain, so nothing new is added to the solution. A powder has a large surface to react with, and using an excess makes sure every bit of copper sulphate is used up; the unused zinc and the copper formed are both solids that can be filtered off.
(b)
Zn(s)+CuSO4(aq)→ZnSO4(aq)+Cu(s)
The purification is complete when:
- the blue tint has disappeared completely and the solution is colourless, and
- adding a little more zinc powder produces no fresh reddish-brown deposit of copper (and no further warming).
The solution is then filtered to remove the copper and the leftover zinc.
(c) Iron is also more reactive than copper, so it would remove the copper:
Fe(s)+CuSO4(aq)→FeSO4(aq)+Cu(s)
But it would replace one impurity with another. The copper sulphate would become iron sulphate, which stays dissolved and cannot be filtered off, and the solution would turn pale green. The aim was to add no new substance, and only zinc, whose sulphate is the product wanted, meets that condition. (Iron also cannot remove itself afterwards, because zinc sulphate does not react with iron, so the iron sulphate would stay.)
