A student places a clean magnesium ribbon in a colourless solution of zinc sulphate and leaves it for an hour. The solution is still colourless afterwards. Her partner says: "There has been no colour change, so no reaction has happened." Which option gives evidence that a reaction did take place, and correctly predicts what happens if a zinc strip is placed in magnesium sulphate solution?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 40 of 79
A student places a clean magnesium ribbon in a colourless solution of zinc sulphate and leaves it for an hour.
- Correct answer
(A) A grey deposit forms on the ribbon and the ribbon becomes thinner; a zinc strip in magnesium sulphate solution shows no change, because zinc is less reactive than magnesium.
(B) There can be no evidence, because both zinc sulphate and magnesium sulphate solutions are colourless; a zinc strip in magnesium sulphate solution also shows no change.
(C) A grey deposit forms on the ribbon; a zinc strip in magnesium sulphate solution also gets a grey coating, because displacement works in both directions.
(D) Bubbles of hydrogen form on the ribbon, proving that zinc has been displaced; a zinc strip in magnesium sulphate solution displaces magnesium because zinc is a heavier metal.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Magnesium is more reactive than zinc, so it displaces zinc from zinc sulphate:
Both salt solutions are colourless, so no colour change is expected; the evidence must come from the solids. Zinc is deposited as a grey coating on the ribbon, and the ribbon gets thinner as magnesium goes into solution. Zinc is less reactive than magnesium, so it cannot displace magnesium from magnesium sulphate, and nothing happens in that tube.
Option (B) is wrong: a colour change is only one sign of a reaction; the deposit and the thinning ribbon show the reaction clearly.
Option (C) is wrong: displacement works in one direction only, from the more reactive metal to the less reactive one, so zinc cannot displace magnesium.
Option (D) is wrong: displacing zinc does not produce hydrogen, and whether a metal displaces another depends on reactivity, not on how heavy it is.

