Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 68 of 79
Three unlabelled bottles, P, Q and R, contain colourless solutions of sodium chloride, sodium sulphate and sodium…
Question 681 markMCQHard
Three unlabelled bottles, P, Q and R, contain colourless solutions of sodium chloride, sodium sulphate and sodium nitrate, in some order. A student does two tests.
Test 1: A little of each solution is put in a test tube and barium chloride solution is added. Only Q gives a thick white precipitate.
Test 2:Fresh samples of P and R are taken and silver nitrate solution is added. P gives a white precipitate that slowly turns grey when the tube is left in sunlight. R shows no change.
Which option identifies the bottles correctly and gives the correct reason for using fresh samples in Test 2?
Select your answer
(A) P is sodium chloride, Q is sodium sulphate, R is sodium nitrate; fresh samples are needed because the tubes from Test 1 now contain chloride from the barium chloride, so silver nitrate would give a white precipitate in every one of them.
Correct answer
(B) P is sodium chloride, Q is sodium sulphate, R is sodium nitrate; fresh samples are needed because barium chloride would decompose the silver nitrate.
(C) P is sodium nitrate, Q is sodium sulphate, R is sodium chloride; fresh samples are needed because the tubes from Test 1 now contain chloride from the barium chloride.
(D) P is sodium sulphate, Q is sodium chloride, R is sodium nitrate; fresh samples are needed because the precipitate from Test 1 would hide any new precipitate.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:Test 1 finds the sulphate. Barium sulphate is insoluble, so only the bottle containing sulphate gives a precipitate with barium chloride:
BaCl2(aq)+Na2SO4(aq)→BaSO4(s)+2NaCl(aq)
So Q is sodium sulphate.
Test 2 finds the chloride. Silver chloride is an insoluble white solid that decomposes in sunlight to grey silver:
So P is sodium chloride, and R, which reacts with neither reagent, is sodium nitrate.
Why fresh samples? Barium chloride itself contains chloride. Every tube from Test 1 now has chloride in it, so silver nitrate added to those tubes would give a white precipitate in all of them and identify nothing. Using fresh samples means the only chloride present is whatever was in the bottle.
Option (B) is wrong: the identities are right, but the reason is invented; silver nitrate is not decomposed by barium chloride, the problem is the chloride that barium chloride adds.
Option (C) is wrong: the precipitate that turns grey in sunlight is silver chloride, so the chloride is in P, not R.
Option (D) is wrong: the bottle that gave a precipitate with barium chloride must be the sulphate, so Q cannot be sodium chloride.