Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Mass is always conserved in a chemical reaction, but an open balance only shows the mass of what stays on the pan. The question in each case is: does anything enter from the air, or leave into the air?
| Experiment | What crosses the boundary | Reading |
|---|
| P | oxygen from the air joins the magnesium | increases |
| Q | hydrogen gas escapes into the air | decreases |
| R | nothing; the solid stays in the beaker | unchanged |
2Mg(s)+O2(g)→2MgO(s)
Zn(s)+H2SO4(aq)→ZnSO4(aq)+H2(g)
BaCl2(aq)+Na2SO4(aq)→BaSO4(s)+2NaCl(aq)
None of these breaks the law of conservation of mass. In P the gain is exactly the mass of oxygen taken from the air; in Q the loss is exactly the mass of hydrogen that left. Only R, where every product stays in the container, shows the law directly on an open balance.
Option (B) is wrong: burning magnesium gains oxygen from the air, so the crucible gets heavier, not lighter.
Option (C) is wrong: it would be true only if all three were sealed; in open containers oxygen enters in P and hydrogen leaves in Q.
Option (D) is wrong: hydrogen escapes in Q, so its reading falls, and in R the precipitate is formed from substances already on the pan, so nothing is added.
