A student writes two general rules in her notebook:
Rule 1: Every combination reaction gives out heat.
Rule 2: Every decomposition reaction needs energy to be supplied.
Which pair of examples, taken together, shows that both rules are wrong?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 60 of 79
A student writes two general rules in her notebook:
Rule 1: Every combination reaction gives out heat.
Rule 2: Every decomposition reaction needs energy to be supplied.
Which pair of examples, taken together, shows that both rules are wrong?
(A) Burning magnesium in air; heating calcium carbonate to make quicklime.
(B) Adding quicklime to water; passing an electric current through acidified water.
(C) Nitrogen and oxygen combining into nitric oxide in a lightning flash, which takes in heat; heating lead nitrate to give lead oxide, nitrogen dioxide and oxygen.
(D) Nitrogen and oxygen combining into nitric oxide in a lightning flash, which takes in heat; vegetable waste decomposing into compost, which gives out heat.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: To show that a rule is wrong you need one example that breaks it: a combination reaction that absorbs heat (against Rule 1), and a decomposition reaction that releases heat (against Rule 2).
Two reactants give a single product, so this is a combination reaction, yet it takes heat in and happens only at the enormous temperature of a lightning flash. It breaks Rule 1.
The decomposition of vegetable matter into compost breaks large compounds into simpler ones, so it is a decomposition, yet a compost heap becomes warm because heat is released. It breaks Rule 2.
So "most combination reactions are exothermic" and "most decomposition reactions are endothermic" are useful patterns, but not laws.
Option (A) is wrong: burning magnesium is an exothermic combination and heating calcium carbonate is an endothermic decomposition, so both examples agree with the rules.
Option (B) is wrong: quicklime and water is an exothermic combination, and electrolysis of water is a decomposition that needs electrical energy, so both examples agree with the rules.
Option (C) is wrong: the nitric oxide example breaks Rule 1, but lead nitrate only decomposes while it is heated, so it agrees with Rule 2 instead of breaking it.
