Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 19 of 79
Two students heat two solids in separate dry boiling tubes.
Question 191 markMCQMedium
Two students heat two solids in separate dry boiling tubes.
Student 1 heats purple-black iodine crystals. Violet vapour fills the tube, and purple-black crystals reappear on the cool upper part of the tube.
Student 2 heats white lead nitrate powder. Brown fumes fill the tube, and a yellow solid is left at the bottom.
Both students see a coloured gas. Which statement correctly compares the two changes?
Select your answer
(A) Both are chemical changes, because a coloured gas is formed in both tubes.
(B) Only Student 2 sees a chemical change: the iodine forms again unchanged on cooling, but lead nitrate gives new substances that do not turn back into lead nitrate.
Correct answer
(C) Only Student 1 sees a chemical change, because the colour changes from purple-black to violet.
(D) Both are physical changes, because both solids are only heated and nothing is added to them.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The test of a chemical change is whether new substances are formed. The violet vapour is iodine itself in the gas state; on cooling it turns straight back into iodine crystals, so no new substance has been formed and the change is physical. Lead nitrate, however, decomposes into substances with completely different properties: yellow lead(II) oxide, brown nitrogen dioxide and oxygen.
2Pb(NO3)2(s)heat2PbO(s)+4NO2(g)+O2(g)
These do not turn back into lead nitrate on cooling, so this change is chemical.
Option (A) is wrong: a coloured gas can be just the vapour of the original substance, as it is with iodine; seeing a gas does not prove that a new substance has formed.
Option (C) is wrong: violet iodine vapour and purple-black iodine crystals are the same substance in different states, so the colour difference is not evidence of a chemical change.
Option (D) is wrong: many chemical changes, such as the decomposition of lead nitrate, need only heat and no added substance.