Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 54 of 79

A student drops a piece of magnesium ribbon into dilute hydrochloric acid.

Question 543 marksHard

A student drops a piece of magnesium ribbon into dilute hydrochloric acid. It fizzes, the test tube becomes warm, and after a minute the ribbon has disappeared, leaving a clear, colourless solution. She writes: "The magnesium has dissolved in the acid, just as sugar dissolves in water. If I evaporate the water, I will get the magnesium back." She evaporates the solution and is left with a white solid.

(a) Write the balanced equation, with state symbols, for what happened, and identify the white solid. [1]

(b) The white solid is dissolved in water and the solution is split into two. Silver nitrate solution added to one part gives a white precipitate that turns grey in sunlight. A clean zinc strip placed in the other part shows no change at all. Explain what each test tells you about the white solid. [1]

(c) Explain the difference between evaporating a sugar solution and evaporating this solution, and classify the reaction of magnesium with the acid by type and by energy change. [1]