A student writes the equation for burning magnesium in air as:
He points out that there is one magnesium atom and one oxygen atom on each side, so the equation is balanced. What is wrong with his equation?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 10 of 79
A student writes the equation for burning magnesium in air as:
He points out that there is one magnesium atom and one oxygen atom on each side, so the equation is balanced. What is wrong with his equation?
(A) Oxygen in air exists as molecules, so the reactant must be written ; the correct balanced equation is .
(B) Nothing is wrong; it is a correct balanced equation, simply written in its shortest form.
(C) The product should be written , so that oxygen can be shown as without adding any coefficients.
(D) Magnesium should be written , because metals, like oxygen, exist as pairs of atoms.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: An equation must use the correct formula for every substance as it actually exists. The oxygen in air is made of molecules of two atoms, , not single atoms, so writing "O" describes a substance that is not there. Once is written, balancing by changing only the coefficients gives:
Check: Mg 2 = 2, O 2 = 2.
Option (B) is wrong: atoms do balance as written, but "O" is not the formula of the oxygen that reacts, so the equation does not describe the real reaction.
Option (C) is wrong: magnesium oxide is ; changing a formula to make atoms balance turns it into a different substance. Only coefficients may be changed.
Option (D) is wrong: metals are written with the symbol of a single atom, Mg; they do not exist as two-atom molecules.
