Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Under the student's idea, the F1 plant receives one piece carrying R and y (from the round green parent) and one piece carrying r and Y (from the wrinkled yellow parent). It is round and yellow. Each germ cell gets one whole piece, so the F1 can make only two kinds of germ cell, Ry and rY, in equal numbers. Combining these:
- Ry + Ry gives RRyy, round green (1 in 4)
- Ry + rY or rY + Ry gives RrYy, round yellow (2 in 4)
- rY + rY gives rrYY, wrinkled yellow (1 in 4)
No germ cell carries both r and y, so a wrinkled green seed (rryy) can never form. The result would be round yellow : round green : wrinkled yellow = 2 : 1 : 1. This is exactly why the book argues that the genes must be on separate pieces: wrinkled green seeds do appear in the real F2.
(A) 9 : 3 : 3 : 1 is what Mendel actually found, and it requires the genes to be passed on independently, the opposite of the student's idea.
(B) In this cross R arrived with y, not with Y. Round yellow and wrinkled green would be the only classes if the parents had been RRYY and rryy.
(C) In the F2, an Ry germ cell from one side can meet an rY germ cell from the other, giving RrYy. So round yellow seeds would also appear, and they would be the commonest class.
