An aquarium keeper watches one particular snail over two seasons, as summarised below.

Which conclusion is best supported by this observation?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 31 of 80
An aquarium keeper watches one particular snail over two seasons, as summarised below.

Which conclusion is best supported by this observation?
(A) In this snail, sex is not fixed by the chromosomes it got at fertilisation
(B) The snail's sex chromosomes must have changed from XY to XX as it grew older
(C) The eggs it laid must really have come from a different snail in the same tank
(D) The snail was always a female, and the sperm it seemed to produce were not real
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The same individual functioned first as a male (producing sperm and fertilising other snails' eggs) and later as a female (laying eggs). An individual keeps the same chromosomes it received at fertilisation throughout its life, so if its sex had been fixed by those chromosomes it could not have changed. As the book notes, snails that change sex show that in such animals sex is not genetically determined, unlike in human beings, where it is largely genetic.
(B) Chromosomes do not swap from one kind to another during life; nothing in the observation needs such a change.
(C) The observation is of one snail followed closely; inventing a mix-up ignores the evidence rather than explaining it.
(D) The snail actually fertilised other snails' eggs, so its sperm were real and it was functioning as a male.