A student cut the tips off several young shoots and stood the tips on a small block of agar jelly for a few hours, then threw the tips away. Two more shoots, X and Y, also had their tips removed and were kept in complete darkness. X received the agar block that had held the tips, placed on the left half of its cut surface. Y received a fresh block that had never touched a tip, placed in the same position.

(a) Predict which way X will bend after a day, and explain why it bends even though it is in darkness. [1]
(b) What does the result for Y show, and what conclusion can be drawn about how the shoot tip controls the growth of the stem below it? [1]

