Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Every living cell of a plant, including root cells, respires all the time. Gases are exchanged across the surface of roots by diffusion, so root cells must take their oxygen from their surroundings. In jar P the bubbling air keeps oxygen dissolving in the water. In jar Q the oxygen is soon used up and is not replaced. Glucose can still be broken into pyruvate in the cytoplasm, but the breakdown of pyruvate using oxygen in the mitochondria, the step that releases most energy, cannot take place. The pathways that work without oxygen release much less energy. With too little ATP the root cells cannot carry out their life processes, and they die. Waterlogged soil kills roots in the same way, because water fills the air spaces between soil particles.
(A) Both jars contain the same mineral solution, so the amount of water around the roots is the same. The only difference is the air, which supplies oxygen.
(C) Roots have no chlorophyll and do not photosynthesise in either jar. They receive food from the leaves through the phloem, and that supply is the same for both plants.
(D) Each living cell needs oxygen for aerobic respiration and takes it in by diffusion from its own surroundings; leaves do not supply oxygen to the roots. Both jars hold the same mineral solution, so minerals cannot explain the difference.
