(a) Alcohol (ethanol) is formed only when yeast breaks down pyruvate without oxygen, and that pathway gives ethanol and carbon dioxide together. Since the liquid smells of alcohol, the yeast was fermenting, so the gas collected must be carbon dioxide.
Rate between 20 and 60 minutes =60−2026−6=4020=0.5 cm³ per minute.
A straight line means the gas was being given off at a steady rate. The yeast was respiring anaerobically at a constant rate, which fits the fact that plenty of sugar was still left, so its food was not running out during the hour. (The slower start in the first 10 to 20 minutes is the yeast getting going, and some of the first gas dissolving in the liquid before any could be collected.)
(b) P compared with Q: the only difference is the sugar, and Q gives almost no gas. So the yeast needs sugar as its food (the respiratory substrate) to produce carbon dioxide. The tiny amount of gas in Q at the start probably came from the small store of food already inside the yeast cells, which was soon used up.
P compared with R: the only difference is that the yeast in R was boiled, which kills the cells, and R gives no gas at all. So the carbon dioxide comes from the respiration of living yeast cells, not from the sugar solution on its own.
(c) Filling the flasks and covering them with oil keeps air (oxygen) out, so that the yeast has to respire anaerobically. That is what the experiment set out to study.
With oxygen available, much of the pyruvate would instead be broken down in the mitochondria, completely, into carbon dioxide and water (aerobic respiration). Any two of these predictions:
- Less ethanol would be made from each glucose molecule. Ethanol forms only when pyruvate is broken down without oxygen, so pyruvate that goes to the mitochondria makes none. (Yeast in plenty of sugar may still make some ethanol, so the answer is "less", not "none".)
- Water would be formed as a product, which fermentation does not produce.
- More carbon dioxide would be given off per glucose molecule. In the mitochondria each three-carbon pyruvate is broken into three molecules of carbon dioxide, so all its carbon leaves as CO₂. In fermentation part of the carbon stays behind in the ethanol.
- Much more energy would be released per glucose molecule, because aerobic respiration breaks glucose down completely.
