Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Terrestrial animals take oxygen from the air through organs whose structure increases the surface area in contact with air. Because oxygen and carbon dioxide have to be exchanged across this surface, it must be very fine and delicate. To protect it, it is usually placed within the body. This is why there have to be passages that take air to it, and a mechanism for moving air in and out: in humans, the ribs and diaphragm. The student's exposed sacs would be damaged and would lose water to the air, so they would soon stop working. Gills can sit near the outside because they are bathed in water, not dry air.
(A) Carbon dioxide passes from the blood into the air across the same exchange surface that takes in oxygen. Breathing out through the nose only removes air from inside the lungs. An exposed surface would release carbon dioxide directly into the air.
(B) Oxygen and carbon dioxide move by diffusion across the exchange surface, whether or not the air is moving. Breathing movements are needed in real lungs because the surface is deep inside the body, where air must be brought to it.
(C) The air reaching the alveoli comes from outside, so it holds no more oxygen than outside air. The problem is protecting the surface, not the oxygen content of the air.
