Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: On the sunny day the oxygen rose from 5 to 12 mg/L by mid-afternoon; on the overcast day, at the same temperature, it rose only to about 6 mg/L. The rise therefore depends on light, which is what the water weeds need to photosynthesise and give out oxygen. Every night the oxygen fell steadily. In the dark no oxygen is made, but the fish, snails, weeds and the bacteria and fungi in the mud all go on using oxygen for respiration, so the level falls. The oxygen in the water is an abiotic component, and here the biotic components are changing it: living things and their physical surroundings act on each other in both directions.
(A) The temperature was the same on both days, yet the oxygen rose far more on the sunny day. Warmth does not explain the difference; light acting through the weeds does.
(B) The level falls every night, so nothing is adding oxygen in the dark. Fish use oxygen; they do not give it out.
(C) Light matters only because the weeds use it. If living things played no part, nothing would use up the oxygen at night, yet it fell every night.