A student carried out three tests with pieces of the same polythene film and some banana peel.

Which conclusion is best supported by all three results taken together?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 67 of 80
A student carried out three tests with pieces of the same polythene film and some banana peel.

Which conclusion is best supported by all three results taken together?
(A) Polythene is biodegradable, because test 1 shows that it can be broken down and changed into another form.
(B) Heat and pressure can change polythene, but nothing in ordinary soil breaks it down, so there it persists.
(C) The soil used in test 2 had no living decomposers in it, and that is the only reason the film stayed unchanged.
(D) Polythene cannot be changed by any process at all, which is why it was still intact after five years in soil.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Test 1 shows that polythene can be acted upon by physical processes such as heat and pressure: at 200 °C under high pressure it melted and took a new shape. Test 2 shows that in moist soil at ordinary temperatures (15 to 35 °C) the film was not broken down at all in five years. Test 3, in the same soil, shows that the soil was full of active decomposers, because the banana peel was gone within 4 weeks. So the film persisted not because decomposers were missing but because they cannot break polythene down, and the heat and pressure that can change it are not found under the ambient conditions of the environment. This is exactly why NCERT says plastics persist in the environment for a long time.
(A) Melting under heat and pressure is a physical change; the film was not broken down by any biological process. Biodegradable means broken down by biological processes, which test 2 shows does not happen.
(C) Test 3 used the same soil and the peel disappeared in 4 weeks, so living decomposers were present. Their absence cannot explain the result.
(D) Test 1 shows that polythene can be changed, by heat and pressure. It persists in soil only because such conditions are absent there.